The practice whereby Nigerian businessmen obtain dollars at
official rate and resell at a higher rate at the parallel market is still
continuing, emir of Kano, Muhammadu Sanusi ll, has said.
“We have created our own billionaires since 2015 from foreign
exchange subsidy,” the emir said in a speech at 15th Joint
National Council on Development Planning meeting held in Kano
They got the dollar at N197 and price their goods at N300, he
said in his speech tilled “Nigeria: The search for new growth
“For instance, when the CBN was selling dollar at N197 and
people were buying at N300, if I sit down in my garden and pick
up my phone I would have enough people to call in the industry
to get 10 million dollars at officials rate and sell at N300 and
make a profit of over N1bn and if I do that four times in a year,
for doing nothing I would have earned N4bn.
“And people were telling us that this policy was to help the poor.
We should not devalue because if we do the poor people would
People that were profiting from this were the ones telling the
government that if you devalue people would suffer; meanwhile
they all got the dollar at N197 and price their goods at N300.
“The poor paid the price of the devalued currency and the rich
schemed up the profits and it went on for one year and we talked
and talked and talked. “If the present administration continues to
behave the way the immediate past government behaved, we will
end up where Jonathan ended. You may not like it but that is the
He added that one needs not be an economist to know that any
system that allows someone to make N1bn profit through a
phone call without investing a kobo is a wrong system and
He pointed out that the economics aspect of the whole thing was
that for every one billion dollars that was taken from the
federation account and sold by the CBN at N197, the states were
losing N100bn that can go into salaries, into agriculture and into
At the same time, he said, the states were going back to borrow
from the same government on the bailout when the government
was selling its dollars to a group of people.
“What kind of economy are we running? Who is advising the
government? I want know who is advising the government so that
I can talk to the adviser.
“We didn’t have money, oil price has collapsed, avengers were
blowing oil wells and the scarce dollars we had we are selling
cheaply to some few individuals.”
The emir said manufacturers have abandoned production and
embarked on foreign exchange business at the expense of
unemployment and local production.
He lamented that it was unfortunate that while other countries are
developing Nigeria has no ambitions as a nation, saying “Do we
really love our country? Do we feel any shame when we see
Malaysia that collected palm oil seed from us is now exporting
He recalled that the Nigerian public sector wage bills went up
from N443bn in 2005 to N1.7trn in 2012, adding that in 2010
when the government increased minimum wage to N18, 000, he
had personally protested because government would basically
rely on borrowing to pay salaries and that would not be
However, he said Nigeria is not all about oil since oil contributes
only 15 per cent to the GDP, adding that if the entire Nigeria’s oil
reserves were sold today, the proceeds would only add 1164
dollars per head compared to GDP per capital of 3,000 in 2016.
“So those that are making noise about oil should stop and those
that are afraid about oil should stop. Oil is just a working capital
… that when we sell it we get the dollars that we can use to
import. If we can have another source of working capital we can
do without it.”
The emir commended the FG for making some changes in the
economic system including removal of wasteful subsidies, noting
that the country should rather subsidise in production not
He pointed out that Nigeria is spending 6-7 billion dollars per
annum on fake subsidies and all the money goes to private jets,
expensive jewelleries, and properties abroad and so on and so
forth, noting that nothing goes to the economy.
The emir added that Nigeria earned 16 billion dollars from the oil
sector in 2011 but not a single dollar went to education, roads
and or power sector. “Every dollar we earned in the oil sector
went back to petroleum subsidy in 2011.”
He advised the FG to also focus on power generation and land
reform as well in its effort to diversify the nation’s economy.
The emir said he is a friend of the present administration “but if
they decide to run Nigeria aground, I will become the opposition.
You are not good friends with government officials and don’t tell
them the truth. I will continue to say the truth.”
The Emir attributed the current economic recession in the country
to inability of the past administrations to diversify the economy.
He said there was urgent need for the country to return to the
drawing board and expand the economy through wise investment
for the economic growth and development of the country.
“If we do not expand the economy through wise investment, we
can end up in classical Malthusian situation.
He lamented that in spite of the past experiences we had on our
socio-economic challenges, the country was still making the
same mistakes as we cannot process tomato paste.“Tomato
paste is being imported from China. It is sad, “he said